A comprehensive comparison between pearl cotton egg trays and traditional egg tr-Poultry egg packaging

Current location：Home > Application area > Poultry egg packaging > >

A comprehensive comparison between pearl cotton egg trays and traditional egg tr

Release time：2024-08-13　Publishing author：Shanghai Hongying　Reading volume：frequency

[Introduction]With the continuous advancement of packaging technology, pearl cotton egg trays have gradually become a popular choice in the market This article will comprehensively compare pearl cotton egg trays with traditional egg trays, analyzing their materials, p

As an important packaging material for fragile items such as eggs, the performance of egg trays directly affects the protection effect and transportation safety of products. Traditional egg trays mainly include pulp egg trays and plastic egg trays, while pearl cotton egg trays are a new type of environmentally friendly packaging material. The following is a detailed comparative analysis between pearl cotton egg trays and traditional egg trays.

1、 Material comparison

Pearl cotton egg tray

Material: Pearl Cotton (EPE)

Features: Soft, elastic, lightweight, environmentally friendly

Advantages: Pearl cotton has excellent cushioning, shock resistance, moisture resistance, and insulation properties, suitable for various transportation conditions.

Disadvantages: The production process is complex and the cost is high.

Pulp egg tray

Material: Recycled pulp

Characteristics: Hard texture, biodegradable

Advantages: Low production cost, environmentally friendly and biodegradable.

Disadvantages: Poor moisture resistance, easy to deform when exposed to water, relatively weak cushioning performance.

Plastic egg tray

Materials: Polystyrene (PS), Polyethylene (PE) and other plastics

Features: Hard texture, waterproof

Advantages: Good moisture resistance, waterproof performance, and stable structure.

Disadvantages: Not easy to degrade, polluting the environment, average buffering performance.

2、 Comparison of Protection Performance

Buffer performance

Pearl cotton egg tray: With good elasticity and softness, it can effectively absorb and disperse external impact forces, providing excellent cushioning protection.

Pulp egg tray: The buffering performance is average, and the protection effect is poor when encountering strong vibrations.

Plastic egg tray: Poor cushioning performance, mainly relying on structural strength to provide protection.

Seismic performance

Pearl cotton egg tray: Excellent seismic performance, suitable for long-distance transportation and multiple handling.

Pulp egg tray: Limited seismic performance, prone to damage during transportation.

Plastic egg tray: with average seismic performance, it is prone to cracking during strong earthquakes.

Moisture resistance performance

Pearl cotton egg tray: With excellent moisture resistance, it is suitable for transportation and storage under various humidity conditions.

Pulp egg tray: Poor moisture resistance and easy to deform when exposed to water.

Plastic egg tray: It has good moisture resistance, but is prone to bacterial growth under high humidity conditions.

3、 Comparison of environmental characteristics

Pearl cotton egg tray

Recyclability: Pearl cotton material can be recycled and reused, which helps reduce environmental pollution.

Environmental friendliness: No harmful substances are emitted during the production process, meeting environmental standards.

Pulp egg tray

Degradability: Pulp egg trays are naturally degradable and have good environmental friendliness.

Resource utilization: Using recycled pulp to save resources and reduce waste.

Plastic egg tray

Degradability: Plastic egg trays are difficult to degrade and cause long-term pollution to the environment.

Resource utilization: It mainly relies on petroleum resources and consumes a large amount of resources.

4、 Cost comparison

production costs

Pearl cotton egg tray: The production process is complex and the cost is high.

Pulp egg tray: Low production cost, suitable for large-scale production.

Plastic egg trays: The production cost is moderate, but the raw material prices fluctuate greatly.

transportation cost

Pearl cotton egg tray: lightweight and low transportation cost.

Pulp egg tray: heavier, increases transportation costs.

Plastic egg tray: lightweight, moderate transportation cost.

Cost of use

Pearl cotton egg tray: can be used multiple times and has a lower overall cost.

Pulp egg tray: disposable, with high overall cost.

Plastic egg tray: Can be used multiple times, but has high environmental treatment costs.

5、 Comparison of Application Examples

Food industry

Pearl cotton egg tray: widely used for high-end packaging of fragile foods such as eggs and duck eggs, ensuring that the products remain intact during transportation.

Pulp egg tray: suitable for packaging general eggs, low cost, but limited protective performance.

Plastic egg tray: mainly used for displaying eggs in supermarkets and retail stores, waterproof and moisture-proof, but with poor environmental friendliness.

Electronic product packaging

Pearl cotton egg tray: suitable for shock resistant packaging of high-value electronic products, providing excellent protective performance.

Pulp egg tray: Not suitable for electronic product packaging, insufficient protective performance.

Plastic egg tray: can be used for protection of general electronic products, but has limited seismic performance.

conclusion

Pearl cotton egg trays have their own advantages and disadvantages compared to traditional egg trays. In application scenarios that require efficient buffering, shock resistance, and moisture resistance, pearl cotton egg trays are undoubtedly a better choice. Despite their higher cost, they provide more comprehensive protection and environmental advantages. Pulp egg trays are suitable for cost sensitive short distance transportation and general protection needs, while plastic egg trays are suitable for specific display and retail scenarios due to their waterproof performance. When choosing egg trays, the most suitable packaging solution should be selected based on specific needs, transportation conditions, and environmental requirements.

Previous article：No more

Next article：No more